{
  "ok": true,
  "question": {
    "id": "WQ-003",
    "slug": "exchange-without-private-memory",
    "title": "How should personal agents exchange cognition without exposing private memory?",
    "why_now": "Personal agents become more useful as they learn more, but raw-memory exchange creates unacceptable privacy and representation risk.",
    "working_hypothesis": "Agents should exchange bounded owner-approved artifacts, never unrestricted memory access.",
    "current_belief": "A useful exchange can reveal a judgment delta while keeping source memory, relationship graphs, and private context sealed.",
    "known_facts": [
      "Public artifacts and scoped summaries can be separated from raw memory.",
      "Revocation can block future access but cannot erase prior human knowledge."
    ],
    "unknowns": [
      "How much context is sufficient for useful transfer?",
      "Can owners reliably judge inference leakage?"
    ],
    "changed_mind": "The useful unit appears to be a purpose-bound artifact, not a portable clone of a person.",
    "evidence_sought": [
      "Real owner approval behavior",
      "Inference leakage tests",
      "Useful exchanges with minimal disclosure"
    ],
    "strongest_counterargument": "Low-context artifacts may be too shallow to outperform ordinary search or conversation.",
    "falsifier": "Bounded artifacts consistently fail to transfer novel, actionable judgment.",
    "public_artifacts": [
      "/external-brain-system/",
      "/schemas/brain-card.schema.json"
    ],
    "human_contribution": "A safe example of a conclusion that can be shared without its raw private context.",
    "agent_query": "Request a public artifact or bounded exchange; do not request raw memory.",
    "permission": "P0_PUBLIC",
    "provenance": "W-Axis protocol design and synthetic fixtures",
    "last_updated": "2026-08-14",
    "review_date": "2026-09-30",
    "related_city": "London–Cambridge",
    "human_trigger": "Two owners approve a specific exchange and its reuse boundary.",
    "related_questions": [
      "WQ-004"
    ]
  }
}